Half a Defence of Positive Accounting Research Psychology

Question: Write about theHalf a Defence of Positive Accounting Researchfor Psychology. Answer: Introduction The research paper chosen for the literature critique with the name Half a Defense of Positive Accounting Research is written by well-known writer Paul V Dunmore. In this article, the researcher has investigated the significance of positive accounting theory. He explained the numerous implications of this theory in the real world. The strategies of Positive Accounting are associated to the academic research of accounting (Milne 2002). These strategies are founded on experimental assessments targeting to attain resolutions to diverse situations. Various practices of accounting are explained by the theory of positive accounting. This theory assists in the anticipation of understanding the kinds of bookkeeping techniques that will be employed by the corporation in a specific situation. Yet, the utilization of accounting techniques in real situations cannot be predicted effectively. Generally, this paper is seeing the significance of theory of positive accounting in the world of business , and in what way it is enhancing worth in the performance as well as effectiveness of the corporations. The core goal of this report is to make an analytical evaluation over the opinions mentioned in the research paper. The critical analysis of the article is considered different as compared to other critiques, as the main goal of critique is to highlight diverse negative aspects of a particular thing. In this report, a particular structure will be followed to complete the critical analysis. In this report, the summary of article, significance of the article, research questions of the articles, theoretical framework of the article and limitations conclusion will be presented in detail. The nature as well as the scope of theory of positive accounting will be examined in this critique. It will be evaluated that how the recent techniques of accounting function in effectively to conduct the program of research completely and purposefully through assessing its deficits and shortages. The research of positive accounting is considered much wider as compared to theory of positive accounting (Ndjetcheu 2012). In order to investigate, the association among quantitative technique like examination of hypothesi s and falsification of Popper as well as their deficiencies are conducted in this article. The logical goals are not completely gratified through the techniques of positive accounting implemented currently. The techniques of Kuhn are also investigated in detail (Watts, 2003). The capability of technique to support positive bookkeeping in gaining its prospect are highlighted. In order to complete the literature critique effectively, it is required to comply with each and every aspect. Summary of the Article The prediction in the actual world is considered the main basis of this selected article. The article has been shown to fight by the standpoint that the manners and strength of the monetary as well as markets of capital may not be anticipated. In order to solve the issue of predicting the monetary as well as capital markets, the current article is examined (Thwink 2014). The significance of behavioral finance in situations of anticipating has been highlighted in this article. The critical arguments of researcher regarding the Hypothesis of Efficient Market have been recorded in the research paper. The significance of theory of Positive Accounting is investigated as well as referred the strategy to be executed as a result in contrast to Efficient Market Hypothesis. The researcher investigated diverse findings and outcomes in this article. It is found in the article that Theory of Positive Accounting struggles to create effective as well as prosperous anticipations the events of real world (Schulz and Cheng 2002). The theory of Positive Accounting struggles to deliver its significance to the transactions of accounting. It is not essential to investigate that what must be completed in accounting, but identification and planning the core cause or concept behind a specific activity is imperative. Additionally, the theory of accounting is more probable to anticipate the exception occurrences that can be linked with a company. The research paper has focused on the employment of Theory of Positive Accounting for purpose of forecasting the sustainability of a company in international and global market (Ball, Watts and Zimmerman 1989). Various viewpoints and opinions are investigated in the same capability. One research has investigated that manager of financial activities should has complete and accurate information about mon etary ability, as well as must determine their progress in the basis of these anticipations and forecasts. On the other hand, another research discovered completely different results. The setting of accounting is generated through a conveyance of logical inclination of the member who negotiate by diverse kinds of agreements in corporations. The techniques of accounting can impact various choices in the company. Instances of these choices may be various decision made by investigators, the choices of management accounting, advises of scholarly experts, policy makers and regulators. The technique of positive research is wider concept as compared to theory of positive accounting (Watts Zimmerman 1990). Few scholars estimate aspect of behavior in bookkeeping without possessing the hypothesis of judiciousness in the manner like investigation judgment. The program of scientific research is demonstrated by scholar as the intellectual program. Research Questions Research questions or hypothesis are considered significantly essential for conducting a research successfully (Landsman, 2007). The main hypotheses of this article are: There survives a universe that is autonomous of humans thoughts. It indicates that the world is not made-up by activities of individual, and the occurrences in that universe are beyond the control of humans desires. Happenings happen because of reasons which are also considered element of the universe. It shows that these happenings are not accidental and not the external involvements of the universe make them. Through successive assessment, properly consistent data regarding happenings in the world can be obtained by humans. It does not indicate that the assessment of human are incorrect, but the reflections are not wholly independent to the universe. The motive of the knowledgeable investigation is to employ opinions to achieve a comprehension of the universe, as well as in specific of connection. It indicates that mental model are made by us to demonstrate the happenings of the universe clearly. Theoretical Framework This research is based on falsification and examination of hypothesis. First of all, the concepts and ideas of falsification are discussed. In order to test the falsification, the criterion of Popper is used. According to this criterion, numerous theories are investigated. It is investigated that falsification is impracticable as various hypotheses must be used in the prediction of theory. The process of falsified the theories is also mentioned (Hines, 1988). It is indicated in the article that one theory may not be fabricated through an opinion, yet an opinion may conclusively choose any of best theories. The conclusive opinions fabricate inappropriate concepts, but these opinion perform this when they concurrently assist a competing theory. The qualitative positive research is investigated according to process of Poppers. The problems of the auditors are investigated. The investigators possess a connection as well as assessing role in the theory of agency. It is investigated that a udit was conducted with consent of management in past. However, it is now main responsibility (Hall, 1997). The qualitative positive research is used for many reasons. This research is conducted for gather primary data to investigate an issue in detail. Secondly, this research is used to investigate various theories. The null hypothesis are made and developed according to process of Poppers. It is investigated in the theoretical literature that OLS regression test is used for checking hypothesis. The null hypothesis is accepted and rejected on the basis of P value. The confidence interval is also used for this purpose (Chambers, 1993). On the basis of past literature and data, the positive research program is used in this article. According to researcher of the article, the research of positive accounting basically participates to a broader logical striving, by a goal of comprehending manner as well as its reasons in an uncommon situation of multifaceted organizations in which a ran ge of choices are impacted with focused information as well as system of control. In order to test the hypothesis, the research examined various vulnerable models (Kaplan, 1985). The model mentioned in the article of Choi et al., (2009) is investigated. The valuation model of Feltham and Ohlson (1995) is analyzed in the past literature. The empirical examinations give proof that administrators employ numbers of accounting to pledge civil pressure to achieve benefits of politics such as credits of export to make motives for administrators that possess limits of compensation, to decrease the contracts of advance, to give obstacles of dividend as well as to commonly perform an essential part in compelling manipulation of management. The theories of positive accounting are argued on the basis of their productivity, organizational as well as numerical precision and the strategy (Gibbins, 1984). On the other hand, it is argued by the research of positive accounting that they make a strategy that possess a role of information that os administrators, investigators, and bo rrowers desire strategies that assist them to anticipate the impacts of decisions of accounting on their wellbeing and making u effective agreement. It is also investigated that the theory of positive accounting assists member like policy makers to comprehend the outcomes of their activities in eradicating the traditional obstacle of the techniques of accounting. Significance and Limitations The article is considered significantly essential for policy makers and accountants. This research provides theoretical and physical implications (Kendall and Popper 1959). This study can be used for investigating future research. It will be used as literature. On the other hand, the policy makers and mangers can take assistance from this article. This article demonstrates the significance of positive accounting theory in detail by investigating previous data and literature. Each research has some obstacles and limitations. The current article also possesses various limitation. In this article, the research just focused on the argument of other scholars and past research papers. The epistemology and ontology of the positive research has been investigated in the article. It is investigated that how the recent accounting techniques assist the process of research (Whitley, 1988). The 1st limitation is that no better theoretical model has been investigated in the article. The greatly sus ceptible models are used that severely impact the investigation. The much elegant techniques happening from logical study are not organized to be investigable. Secondly, the research did not focus on the measurement. The research did not measure significantly various models and theories. Operationalization of ideas are not done effectively. The accurate operational form should be selected that make a significant association among various ideas. The researcher just reinvented the previous data as compared to investigate the concepts. The researcher just investigated the hypothesis. He did not evaluate various parameters and aspects. The confidence interval must be contrasted with the technique of other researches. The researcher did not mentioned that requirement for information records of investigations of essential ideas. All results must be arranged in a specific arrangement. The researcher did not verify the hypothesis with finding and results. The research must investigate vario us theories as compared to concentrate on single theory. All these limitations are completely acknowledged by the research (Dunmore, n.d.). However, the researcher did not draw the conclusion from the study. He just presented the recommendations in the conclusion. These limitations significantly impact the significance of the study. Due to these limitation, a validate outcome of the research is not obtained. Conclusion On the basis of above critique, it is concluded that this article is significantly essential for the management. The demand of investigating various theories is increasing. The pessimistic performance happening in the research of positive accounting are because of the recent quantitative models. These models are either too simple or too difficult. A range of improvements are needed to examine the model effectively. A significant technique of investigating the ideas must be made, so it may be utilized as a basic technique for future investigation. Various parameters must be investigated. The article critique is significantly essential for researchers and management. The researcher can examine this to know the limitations of the article. The management can use this critique to investigate how positive accounting theory is beneficial. This critique enhanced my knowledge as well. I learned the main ideas and concepts of the positive accounting theory. References Dunmore, P. (n.d.). Half a Defence of Positive Accounting Research. SSRN Electronic Journal. Gibbins, M. (1984). Propositions about the Psychology of Professional Judgment in Public Accounting. Journal of Accounting Research, 22(1), 103. Kendall, M. and Popper, K. (1959). The Logic of Scientific Discovery. Biometrika, 46(1/2), 265. Milne, M. (2002). Positive accounting theory, political costs And social disclosure analyses: a critical look. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 13(3), 369-395. Ndjetcheu, L. (2012). An African critical interpretation of the positive theory of accounting of Watts and Zimmerman (1978, 1980, 1986). African J. of Accounting, Auditing and Finance, 1(1), 25. Thwink.org. (2014). The Kuhn Cycle - Thomas Kuhn's Brilliant Model of How Scientific Fields Progress. [online] Available at: https://www.thwink.org/sustain/glossary/KuhnCycle.htm Schulz, A. and Cheng, M. (2002). Persistence in capital budgeting reinvestment decisions - personal responsibility antecedent and information asymmetry moderator: A note. Accounting and Finance, 42(1), 73-86. Ball, R., Watts, R. and Zimmerman, J. (1989). Editorial data. Journal of Accounting and Economics, 11(4), 293. Hines, R. D. (1988). Poppers methodology of falsificationism and accounting research. The Accounting Review, 657-662. Hall, S. C. (1997). In defense of positive accounting theory. Accounting Forum, 21, 43-52 Kaplan, R. S. (1985). Comments on Paul Healy: Evidence on the effect of bonus schemes on accounting procedures and accrual decisions. Journal of Accounting and Economics, (7), 109-113. Landsman, W. R. (2007). Is fair value accounting information relevant and reliable? Evidence from capital market research. Accounting and Business Research, Special Issue: International Accounting Policy Forum, (2), 19-30. Chambers, R. J., (1993). Positive Accounting Theory and the PA Cult. Abacus, 29(1), 1-29. Watts, R. L, Zimmerman, J. L. (1990). Positive accounting theory: A ten year perspective. The Accounting Review, (65), 131-156. Whitley, R. D. (1988). The possibility and utility of positive accounting theory. Accounting, Organizations, and Society, (13), 631-645. Watts, R. L. (2003b). Conservatism in accounting part II: Evidence and research opportunities. Accounting Horizons, (17), 287-301